Memes and online urban legends sometimes spread like wildfire on the Internet, but it can be hard to find where they originate. One creepy image has been ubiquitous in online spaces since the 2000s. Today we discuss the spread and unknown origins of the image associated with the “creepypasta” Jeff the Killer. Visit our Twitter (https://twitter.com/RedWebPod) to see the images we mention. Sponsored by Audible (go to http://audible.com/redweb or text redweb to 500-500 to try Audible free for 30 days), Aura Frames (go to http://auraframes.com/redweb to get $30 off their Carver Mat frames), and Honey (go to http://joinhoney.com/redweb to get Honey for free).