Appalachian Mysteria investigates true murder mysteries in the Appalachian Mountain region. The podcast's first season examines the decapitation of two college freshmen at West Virginia University in 1970. Their heads remain undiscovered. Some believe their killer does also, despite a conviction. J. Kendall Perkinson, Sarah James McLaughlin, and Geoff Fuller research crimes and share their findings on the podcast.
Perkinson is a multimedia journalist and founder of Kromatic Media. Fuller is a New York Times bestselling author of crime novels. McLaughlin found her grandmother's crime and gore books as a child. She developed an interest in the WVU murders of Karen Ferrell and Mared Malarik. Her fascination prompted this podcast. McLaughlin cowrote a book about these murders with Fuller. They interview jurors, victims, reporters, and witnesses on this podcast. The hosts even attend criminal trials. Appalachian Mysteria listeners hear every detail.
Season two of the podcast studies the murder of Alexander Stevens. His body appeared in Savage River State Forest next to evidence of a ritual. Other seasons discuss different crimes. One involved a lesbian couple who disappeared after hiking the Appalachian Trail. The crimes discussed here on Appalachian Mysteria aren't standard. They involve intersex child molesters, psychic cults, and recanted confessions. There are ghost hitchhikers, an assassination attempt on a prosecutor, and police errors. One police officer opens an envelope, and the victim's fingertips fall onto his desk. Police receive a confessional letter that describes where to find the bodies. The signature is a triangle, not a name.
The hosts express their thoughts on wrongful convictions and propose possible suspects. Appalachian Mysteria listeners might feel like they're part of these investigations. They also learn about the area. Perkinson, McLaughlin, and Fuller play local musicians' songs in the background. The hosts describe living in the mountains that Perkinson calls beautiful yet terrifying. The Appalachian Mountains contain 24,000 square miles of dense forest. Fog and mist often obstruct the view. It's an ideal setting for crimes to go unsolved. That's unacceptable to these hosts, who pursue justice.
Season 4
Season 3
Season 2