Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans is a podcast for true crime fans. Joined by her husband Austin, host Kelly analyzes true crime stories moment by moment. She examines the crimes themselves, as well as the investigations that follow. Her thorough research into every case offers listeners a complete overview of every event.

Austin acts as a proxy for the listener, unaware of most of the cases on the show. Kelly reveals the details of the stories to the audience as she does to Austin. She saves the truth of the case for the end of the episode, letting Austin guess what happened. In some episodes, the case remains unsolved. The two hosts then speculate about what may have happened. Kelly's warm, engaging storytelling brings a compassionate voice to Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans.

Kelly chooses a variety of true crime stories to feature on the podcast. There's no specific type of true crime she gravitates toward. This offers listeners variety. Some episodes examine individual deaths like the Fitbit Murder or Shanquella Robinson. Others explore disappearances, like the case of Taylor Wright. The show has even examined serial killers like the Gainesville Ripper. Every case Kelly analyzes delivers a fascinating mystery. Though Austin provides a good dynamic to play off, he's not the only person Kelly invites on the show. Comedian Carolanne Miljavac has joined the podcast on special episodes.

Above all else, Kelly is a mom. She created the podcast for mom listeners. Yet true crime fans of all kinds may find something they like here. Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans listeners praise Kelly's storytelling and Austin's relatable personality. The two hosts have an endearing dynamic that contrasts with the scary mysteries. This podcast discusses murders, disappearances, and serial killers. Fans of true crime may enjoy trying to solve the mystery along with Austin each week. New episodes release every Friday.