Tales to Terrify is a horror fiction podcast. Host Drew Sebesteny chooses two scary works of fiction to present. Some of the short stories come from horror greats like Edgar Allan Poe or H.P. Lovecraft. Drew also shares stories from lesser-known modern authors. Foregoing sound effects or scoring, narrators read the story with no distractions. The skilled narrators let their expressive readings and the authors' words carry the tales.

The range of horror subgenres on Tales to Terrify offers stories for horror fans of all kinds. From ghost stories to cosmic horror, listeners find an engaging variety to enjoy. The show avoids becoming stale or repetitive by using a different author each week. Additionally, the show has a rotating guest reader for every episode. Listeners hear a different style of narration for each story.

Run by volunteers, Tales to Terrify's narrators and editors are passionate. That comes through in every reading. The editors make sure to screen narrators and choose the best ones to read for the show. They also host a yearly contest for listeners to submit a short horror story. The winners get a cash prize, and their stories get produced into a special episode. As a result, the podcast fosters a community of passionate horror fans.

Those interested in hearing a new horror story every week should try Tales to Terrify. However, listeners get more than the story itself. Before the narrator reads the story, Drew offers some historical context and background on the author. His introduction sets the tone for each episode with a fun, dramatic flair. Every story has timestamps in the description. Listeners can search for authors they like. The podcast also offers an opportunity to discover new horror authors to explore. Lovers of horror may not want to miss these terrifying tales.