People who like to watch mysteries in movies and on TV will find a great listen in Mystery to Me. The podcast provides listeners detailed reviews and recaps of mysterious movies and TV shows. This includes political and action thrillers, whodunits, and serious dramas.
Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee host Mystery to Me. The married couple met while investigating a 1978 cold case murder in Indiana. Cain is an investigative journalist and Greenlee is an attorney-cum-investigative journalist. Mystery to Me offers listeners insight into movies, TV shows, and true crime shows. The show reviews movies like Looper, The Fugitive, and Ring of Fear. TV shows like Dragnet, Miami Vice, and The Hardy Boys/Nancy Drew Mysteries get recapped as well. The podcast examines the old, new, obscure, and popular. The hosts discuss an array of productions with a balanced mix of intelligence and humor.
Cain and Greenlee have an undeniable on-air chemistry that permeates the show. Their personalities make the program easy to listen to. Cain jokes that they have "storytelling analysis served with towering heaps of silliness." The Mystery to Me podcast has a lot of laughs, spoilers (listener beware!), and warmth despite the serious topics addressed. The hosts do a great job of examining plot lines, plot holes, and shocking endings.
This podcast will give mystery fans something to anticipate every week. Fans of Mystery to Me may also want to listen to The Murder Sheet. That is a separate true crime podcast that the husband-and-wife team also hosts. The sleuths discovered major leads in the murder of two teenage girls in Delphi, Indiana. That podcast also covered the original 1978 murder case where the hosts first met.
Episodes