Home
Home
Podcasts
Podcasts
Library
Cancel
Sign in
Scare Me Straight
Alexa, Nichole, and Jonathan
Follow
A little spooky, a little queer, and a lot of laughs! Join Alexa, Nichole, and Jonathan on their eternal investigation of the paranormal, the supernatural, the occult, and the downright frightening. We promise not to scare you... too much.
read less
Fiction
Fiction
Start Here
May 6 2024
Ed Gein The Butcher of Plainfield
Ohhhh Scaremestraight listenerssssssssss! What a lovely…skin suit you have… a divine sku… I mean head. What beautiful fingies too. Take a guess who! This week we are diving into the darker side of small-town life! Join us as we explore the twisted tale of Ed Gein, the 'Butcher of Plainfield.' From farmhouse oddities to his eye for fashion, this episode will leave you both intrigued and slightly spooked! Don't miss out on the creepiest conversation of the week! Support the Show.
Episodes
May 6 2024
Ed Gein The Butcher of Plainfield
Ohhhh Scaremestraight listenerssssssssss! What a lovely…skin suit you have… a divine sku… I mean head. What beautiful fingies too. Take a guess who! This week we are diving into the darker side of small-town life! Join us as we explore the twisted tale of Ed Gein, the 'Butcher of Plainfield.' From farmhouse oddities to his eye for fashion, this episode will leave you both intrigued and slightly spooked! Don't miss out on the creepiest conversation of the week! Support the Show.
Apr 19 2024
Elisa Lam - Crime Time with Lizzie!
Support the Show.
Apr 7 2024
The History of Ouija Boards
Hello our dear Scaremestraight listeners!We are getting a little ✨ spiritual ✨ this week by reaching out to the actual spirits! Well, not us directly BUT we are talking about the vehicle people use - the Ouija Board! Get a little history lesson in on your next listen, and join us for another lovely lil’ episode!We love you! 👻🖤Support the Show.
Mar 22 2024
The Dover Demon
Hey hey hey Scaremestraight friends!Are you ready for a new episode? She’s slender. She’s bulbous. She’s got long fingies and long leggies. And she probably came from outer space and got lost on our lovely trash planet, but who knows!This week we are talking about the Dover Demon! Settle in and keke with us! 👽 Support the Show.
Mar 8 2024
The Exorcism of Roland Doe - Part 3
Hey Scaremestraight friends! We hope you’re ready because we’ve got a three parter, and it’s coming today. 👻👻 The chilling conclusion to our journey into the darkness of the exorcism of Roland Doe is finally here! 🕯️🔮 In this final chapter, we witness the ultimate battle between good and evil as priests attempt to rid Roland of the demonic forces that have taken hold of him. The stakes are high, the tension palpable, and the outcome uncertain. Will the power of faith and prayer be enough to save Roland's soul? Or will the darkness prevail? ⚔️💫Stay spooky!Support the Show.
Feb 23 2024
The Exorcism of Roland Doe - Part 2
People of the Scaremestraight pod.What do we love more than an exorcism episode?📢 PART 2 OF AN EXORCISM! 📢Come listen for the rest of the tea Roland Doe was serving. Was the demon purged? Did Roland survive? Did the exorcism work?! Listen and find out you spooky fiends! Support the Show.
Feb 9 2024
The Exorcism of Roland Doe - Part 1
Scaremestraight friends! What do we love more than aliens? More than scary cryptids?! Exorcisms! 👹👻This week we have another lovely story to tell. We are jumping into the exorcism of Roland Doe! And what an adventure this one is… Strap in because she’s got some length to her but we promise you’ll enjoy as much as we did. 😍 Time to get spooky!Support the Show.
Jan 26 2024
Maura Murray - Crime Time with Lizzie!
Hey Scaremestraight friends! Are you ready for another… —-drumroll—-🎶 Crime Time with Lizzie 🎶 Because we definitely are! This week we are delving into the disappearance of Maury Murray, and friends this one was all over. So grab some popcorn. Settle in for that long drive. Wash that hair. Whatever you gotta do, but join us for some more true crime! 👻🚗❄️Support the Show.
Jan 12 2024
Eastern Airlines Flight 401
Oh listenerssss! Are you ready for a little vay-cay?! Well… after this episode you might not be… This week on Scaremestraight we are diving right into the Flight of 401 and the ghosties that follow! We love a traveling girlie. But not everyone feels that way! Please fasten your seat belts, raise your window shades, and remain in your seat for take off because we aren’t liable for ya’ll. Support the Show.
Dec 25 2023
Christmas Legends
🎤 🎶 “He sees you when you’re sleeping…. He knows when you’re awakeeeee……” 🎶 -Record Scratch-Ya’ll should know us by now because we are definitely not talking about the big man in red! Or even his little deer friends. But boy… do we have a yummy treat for you!! On our very special Christmas episode we are bringing you a big bag of Christmas Legends! Join us today after all the festivities for a couple of spooky, scary, and very interesting legends that make the season just a little bit brighter. Merry Christmas and Happiest of Holidays, Scaremestraight listeners!Support the Show.
Dec 6 2023
Legend of the Mothman
Hello dear followers!Are you ready for another cryptids episode? This week we are unmasking the extra ooky spooky MOTHMAN. 🦋👹🦋 ✨✨ We’ve got stories. We’ve got pictures. We’ve got some off the wall theories. Is he an alien? Is he a monster? A prankster?Also, with mothman being so popular who would have thought he was so mysterious?!Join us this week for a fun little cryptid kiki!Support the Show.
Nov 22 2023
Possession of Anneliese Michel
ATTENTION SCAREMESTRAIGHT LISTENERSThere is a special episode coming your way! We are delving into our first supposed ✨possession✨and it’s a little… cray cray, to say the least. This week we are discussing the Possession of . It’s got demons, lots of medication, and some of us even learned a new word!👹👻👹Support the Show.
Nov 3 2023
JonBenet Ramsey - Crime Time with Lizzie!
Hello hellooooo you spooky fiends! It’s your fav podcast coming at you with another episode! Be sure to grab your popcorn and a cute drink because it’s a doozy… and maybe your anxiety meds because woo boy, it’s a lot to take in. 🥲This week we are delving into the murder mystery of JonBenét Ramsey! What a mess what a MESS. Bringing the facts and educating the children 👸 is a lovely returning guest and we could not wait to get into it. Come join us!PSA: Don’t feel bad if you didn’t know who or what this was about. It’s definitely not that blond, mean, cooking guy 🥘🫠.Support the Show.
Oct 18 2023
The Haunting of Jackie Hernandez
Heyyyyyyy all you spooky-ooky ghosties!It’s that time again… can you feel it?! I hope so because this week we have an episode that might just make you shiver and cringe. 👀👀It’s giving ectoplasm… It’s giving hanging off the ceiling… It’s giving straight up angry ghost!! The phantoms are vibin’ ya’ll so come listen and learn about the Haunting of Jackie Hernandez! Support the Show.
Oct 5 2023
Superstition Origins
Spooky bitches UNITE! Hello friends we have another episode for youuuuuu 🎶 This week we are delving into something that almost everyone has… or does… or believes… Do you knock on wood?Throw that salt over your shoulder?Stay away from that black cat?Follow lucky numbers?That’s right! We are talking about Superstitions 👀👻😱 and we have a special guest this week bringing us the hard hitting facts about why we believe them!Come join us!Support the Show.
Sep 20 2023
Lacerta Files & Alien Smash or Pass
Peek-a-boo you spooky bitches! Did you miss us?! Never fear! We are bringing you another episode! And this one is a doozy my ghouls and gals. Put on your tin foil hats and buckle up because we are talking about the Lacerta files! 👽 Never heard of it?? We hadn’t either but we got you boo.Then on the second half of the episode we are playing….A rousing game….Of…SMASH OR PASS ALIEN EDITION 👽❤️🍑🍆Images are in the post! Play along with us! Support the Show.
Sep 5 2023
Cursed Films
Support the Show.
Aug 16 2023
Robert The Doll
🎭 Introducing Robert the Doll: The original influencer before social media even existed! 😱 This iconic doll has a story that will give you goosebumps and make your imagination run wild.👀 Prepare to be spooked... and maybe even develop a case of "paranormal obsession" after learning about Robert's eerie powers. 👻💭 But hey, don't worry! We're just here to entertain you, not haunt your dreams. Share your own theories about this supernatural superstar using #RobertTheDoll and let's conjure up some fun discussions together! 🧙♀️✨🚫 Caution: Keep an eye on your own dolls while browsing through these creepy tales – you never know when they'll decide to come alive! 😳😂 #DontSayWeDidntWarnYouSupport the Show.
Aug 2 2023
The Montauk Project
🎙️Get ready for a wild ride! Our latest podcast episode dives deep into the mysterious world of The Montauk Project. Buckle up, because reality is about to take a vacation! 🛸👽Uncover the secrets, conspiracy theories, and mind-boggling experiments that allegedly took place in one of the most enigmatic locations on Earth. Trust us, you won't find this kind of sci-fi craziness anywhere else! 🌀💡Are you ready to challenge your beliefs and explore the unexplained? Tune in and join us as we go on a journey that'll make Mulder and Scully proud! The truth is out there...or is it? 😉🔥Tag a friend who loves all things mysterious, grab some popcorn, and let's unravel The Montauk Project together. Just make sure you don't accidentally open any wormholes along the way! 😂 #TheMontaukProject #PodcastConspiracySupport the Show.
Jul 27 2023
The Stairs to Nowhere
We were blessed to have our FIRST GUEST HOST for this episode!! Thank you Lizzie for the incredible work for this episode!🎙️ Take a step into the world of mystery and confusion with our latest podcast episode: "The Stairs to Nowhere: A Tale of Endless Puzzles!" 🚶♀️🚶♂️Join us as we unravel the mind-boggling enigma of these mysterious stairs. Are they a shortcut to another dimension? A hidden trap for lost socks? Or just a cosmic joke played by mischievous architects?Prepare to be amazed, bewildered, and entertained as we dive deep into the world of architectural oddities. Tune in and let your imagination run wild! 🌪️But fair warning, listeners - be prepared for quirky theories, unexpected twists, and a few chuckles along the way. Trust us, you won't want to miss this stair-raising adventure! 😄🔥 #PodcastEpisode #StairsToNowhere #JourneyIntoMysterySupport the Show.