Midwest Mysteries

Matt Sizemore

Two highschoolers interested in the paranormal and true crime talk about cases from the Midwest including the Historic Holly Hotel, Amway Grand Plaza Hotel, Mothman, and more. Listen for a fresh perspective and follow for even more! read less
Start Here
2-01 James Strang and Lethal Lovers
Oct 6 2021
2-01 James Strang and Lethal Lovers
Season 2!! To kick things off Bo talks about the mysterious and quite interesting life of James Strang, while Matilyn discusses the insane story of the Lethal Lovers also known as the angels of death.
2-01 James Strang and Lethal Lovers
Oct 6 2021
2-01 James Strang and Lethal Lovers
Season 2!! To kick things off Bo talks about the mysterious and quite interesting life of James Strang, while Matilyn discusses the insane story of the Lethal Lovers also known as the angels of death.
10 Johan Otto Hoch and The Melon Heads
Jul 21 2021
10 Johan Otto Hoch and The Melon Heads
In this episode Bo talks about the serial killer "Johan Otto Hoch" and Matilyn discusses the Urban Legend "The Melon heads" as they end their first season of Midwest Mysteries.
09 Jacob Wetterling and Ghost Ships
Jul 14 2021
09 Jacob Wetterling and Ghost Ships
In this episode Matilyn talks about the tragic case of Jacob Wetterling, and Bo discussed a few different Ghost Ship legends.
08 Wisconsin Urban Legends and GR Bell Tower
Jul 7 2021
08 Wisconsin Urban Legends and GR Bell Tower
In this mysterious episode Bo discussed 4 Wisconsin Urban Legends, and Matilyn talks about the legend of the GR Bell Tower off of Division Ave.
07 La Salle Street Murders and Haunted Lighthouses
Jun 30 2021
07 La Salle Street Murders and Haunted Lighthouses
In this episode Matilyn talks about the La Salle Street Murders of Indianapolis, Indiana and Bo discussed a few haunted lighthouses of Michigan.
06 H.H. Holmes and John Wayne Gacy
Jun 23 2021
06 H.H. Holmes and John Wayne Gacy
Today Bo discusses H.H. Holmes, and Matilyn talks about "the killer clown" John Wayne Gacy
5 Jeffery Dahmer and Urban Legends
Jun 16 2021
5 Jeffery Dahmer and Urban Legends
In this episode Matilyn talks about Jeffery Dahmer, and Bo discusses Urban Legends including Dog Man, Hells bridge, and more.
4 The Lake Michigan Triangle and Gypsy Rose Blanchard
Jun 10 2021
4 The Lake Michigan Triangle and Gypsy Rose Blanchard
In this episode Bo talks about the mysterious Lake Michigan Triangle, and Matilyn talks about the story of Gypsy Rose and the murder of Dee Dee Blanchard.
03 Mothman and Amway Grand Plaza Hotel
May 28 2021
03 Mothman and Amway Grand Plaza Hotel
In this episode Bo discusses the Mothman, and has a quote "Mothman moment" and Matilyn discusses the mysterious Amway Grand Plaza Hotel in Grand Rapids, Michigan
02 Heritage Hill and The Holly Hotel
May 22 2021
02 Heritage Hill and The Holly Hotel
In this episode, Bo and Matilyn discuss the haunted Heritage Hill in Grand Rapids Michigan, and The Holly Hotel in Holly Michigan.
01 Introduction
May 22 2021
01 Introduction
Bo and Matilyn introducing ourselves for our new Midwest Mysteries podcast.