| | | Look at All the Glory Here Erik Pearson, T.J. Anderson & Bridget Adams-King | | | | |
| | | Hear the News Bridget Adams-King, Sarah Beth Tanner, Amanda Giles, Melanie Vitaterna, Elleon Dobias & Erik Pearson | | | | |
| | | Lady Dynamite Joey Harbert | | | | |
| | | Leading the March Bridget Adams-King | | | | |
| | | Hear the News (Reprise) Sarah Beth Tanner, Mike Mazzocca, T.J. Anderson, Kelan M. Smith & Eric Loughlin | | | | |
| | | Workingmen, to Arms! T.J. Anderson, Josiah Robinson & Bridget Adams-King | | | | |
| | | Rise Up! Josiah Robinson, Mike Mazzocca & Joey Harbert | | | | |
| | | The Square, Pt. 1 Bridget Adams-King | | | | |
| | | What These Men Knew T.J. Anderson | | | | |
| | | Revolution Erik Pearson | | | | |
| | | The Square, Pt. 2 Bridget Adams-King, Elleon Dobias, Melanie Vitaterna, Sarah Beth Tanner & Amanda Giles | | | | |
| | | Entr'acte Erik Pearson | | | | |
| | | Blame Original Chicago Cast of Haymarket | | | | |
| | | Letters from My Love Bridget Adams-King & Erik Pearson | | | | |
| | | The Courtroom Circus Bridget Adams-King & Amanda Giles | | | | |
| | | Keep on Talkin', August Spies T.J. Anderson, Amanda Giles & Original Chicago Cast of Haymarket | | | | |
| | | The Order of the Gallows Amanda Giles, Bridget Adams-King, Melanie Vitaterna & Sarah Beth Tanner | | | | |
| | | Hear the News (Reprise 2) Mike Mazzocca, Josiah Robinson, Erik Pearson, T.J. Anderson & Joey Harbert | | | | |
| | | The Order of the Gallows (Reprise) Amanda Giles, Bridget Adams-King, Melanie Vitaterna, Sarah Beth Tanner & T.J. Anderson | | | | |
| | | Lady Dynamite (Reprise) Joey Harbert | | | | |
| | | The Execution Bridget Adams-King, Eric Loughlin, Erik Pearson, T.J. Anderson, Mike Mazzocca & Josiah Robinson | | | | |
| | | Homecoming / Finale Elleon Dobias, Kelan M. Smith, Joey Harbert, Amanda Giles, Sarah Beth Tanner, Melanie Vitaterna, Bridget Adams-King, Erik Pearson, Mike Mazzocca, T.J. Anderson, Josiah Robinson & Eric Loughlin | | | | |