| | | Opening
Rebecca Luker, Peter Marinos, Kimberly Mahon & Joel E. Chaiken | | | | |
| | | Scene: India
Daisy Eagan, Drew Taylor & Peter Samuel | | | | |
| | | There's a Girl
The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
| | | Scene: The Library at Misselthwaite Manor
Robert Westenberg & Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | Scene: A Train Platform in Yorkshire / The House Upon the Hill
Barbara Rosenblat, Daisy Eagan & The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
| | | I Heard Someone Crying
Daisy Eagan, Mandy Patinkin & Rebecca Luker | | | | |
| | | Scene: Mary's Sitting Room / If I Had a Fine White Horse
Alison Fraser & Daisy Eagan | | | | |
| | | A Girl in the Valley
Mandy Patinkin & Rebecca Luker | | | | |
| | | Scene: The Ballroom
Daisy Eagan & Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | It's a Maze
Tom Toner, Daisy Eagan & John Cameron Mitchell | | | | |
| | | Scene: The Greenhouse
Daisy Eagan & Tom Toner | | | | |
| | | Winter's on the Wing
John Cameron Mitchell | | | | |
| | | Scene: The Edge of the Moor
John Cameron Mitchell & Daisy Eagan | | | | |
| | | Show Me the Key
Daisy Eagan & John Cameron Mitchell | | | | |
| | | Scene: Archibald's Library / A Bit of Earth
Mandy Patinkin & Daisy Eagan | | | | |
| | | Storm I
Peter Samuel, Michael De Vries, Peter Marinos, Paul Jackel, Kay Walbye, Patricia Phillips, Rebecca Judd & The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
| | | Lily's Eyes
Robert Westenberg & Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | Storm II
Daisy Eagan, Patricia Phillips, Michael De Vries, Peter Marinos, Rebecca Judd & The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
| | | Scene: Colin's Room
John Babcock & Daisy Eagan | | | | |
| | | Round-Shouldered Man
John Babcock | | | | |
| | | Final Storm
Kay Walbye, Patricia Phillips, Peter Samuel & The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
| | | The Girl I Mean to Be
Daisy Eagan | | | | |
| | | The House Upon the Hill
The Secret Garden Ensemble, Robert Westenberg & Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | Quartet: There's a Man (Transition)
Mandy Patinkin, Robert Westenberg, Kay Walbye & Rebecca Luker | | | | |
| | | Race You to the Top of the Morning
Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | Wick
John Cameron Mitchell & Daisy Eagan | | | | |
| | | Scene: Colin's Room (Reprise)
Daisy Eagan & John Babcock | | | | |
| | | Come to My Garden / Lift Me Up
Rebecca Luker & Joel E. Chaiken | | | | |
| | | Come Spirit, Come Charm
Daisy Eagan, John Cameron Mitchell, Alison Fraser, Rebecca Luker & The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
| | | A Bit of Earth (Reprise)
Kay Walbye, Michael De Vries & Rebecca Luker | | | | |
| | | Scene: The Library / Scene: Mary's Room
Robert Westenberg, Daisy Eagan & Alison Fraser | | | | |
| | | Hold On
Alison Fraser, Daisy Eagan & The Secret Garden Original Broadway Cast | | | | |
| | | Letter Song
Daisy Eagan, Mandy Patinkin & Alison Fraser | | | | |
| | | Where in the World
Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | How Could I Ever Know (From "The Secret Garden")
Rebecca Luker & Mandy Patinkin | | | | |
| | | Finale
Rebecca Luker, Kay Walbye, Michael De Vries & The Secret Garden Ensemble | | | | |
